Practical Magic 2 Review: Sandra Bullock And Nicole Kidman Can't Escape The 90s

Twenty-eight years after the original, Sandra Bullock and Nicole Kidman return as Sally and Gillian Owens in Practical Magic 2. Directed by Susanne Bier, the sequel brings back the beloved witch sisters while introducing the next generation of the Owens family.

The film has plenty of nostalgia, magic and sisterly banter, but the story struggles to justify its long-awaited return. While Bullock and Kidman remain the strongest reason to watch, the sequel often feels trapped in the style and ideas of the 1990s.

Practical Magic 2 Movie Details

Practical Magic 2 Story Overview

Sally Owens (Sandra Bullock) and Gillian Owens (Nicole Kidman) are back, but their lives have moved forward since the events of the 1998 film. Sally has continued to keep magic away from her daughters, Kylie (Joey King) and Antonia (Maisie Williams), after suffering another painful loss. But the Owens family curse refuses to stay buried. When Kylie finds herself caught in a dangerous romantic situation involving Gideon (Xolo Maridueña), Sally and Gillian are pulled back into the world of magic.

Their journey takes them beyond their familiar surroundings and eventually to England, where they encounter new mysteries, strange magical characters and another threat connected to the family's history. The rest of the story focuses on the Owens women confronting their past while trying to protect the next generation.

Practical Magic 2 Review: Nostalgia Cannot Do All The Magic

The biggest problem with Practical Magic 2 is that it feels designed around the memory of the original rather than a strong reason for another story. The sequel brings back the familiar ingredients — witches, family curses, sisterhood, eccentric characters and the famous midnight margaritas — but struggles to make them feel fresh. The film also plays heavily with nostalgia. Even the characters and their relationships are repeatedly pushed toward ideas that worked in the original, making the sequel feel more like a reunion than a natural continuation.

The screenplay has some fun moments, but the plot becomes increasingly messy as it moves from the Owens family home to England. The Guardian also noted that the film leans heavily on nostalgia while still finding some charm in the unusual Owens family dynamic. The pacing is another issue. At 130 minutes, the movie takes its time getting through a story that does not always have enough material to justify its length.

Also Read: Resident Evil Review: Zach Cregger's 97-Minute Horror Ride

Sandra Bullock And Nicole Kidman Remain The Best Part

If there is one thing that still works, it is the chemistry between Sandra Bullock and Nicole Kidman. Their sibling arguments and playful exchanges bring much-needed energy whenever the story starts to drag. Bullock, in particular, gets some of the film's better comic moments. The Indian Express highlighted the sibling banter between the two stars and praised Bullock's comic timing.

Kidman gets to embrace Gillian's more eccentric personality, and she clearly seems comfortable returning to the role. Joey King and Maisie Williams help carry the next-generation storyline, while Lee Pace adds another eccentric presence as Ian. Dianne Wiest and Stockard Channing also return as Jet and Franny. However, the supporting characters are not given enough space to make the same impact as the central sisters.

Magic And Visual Appeal

The film looks polished and maintains the autumnal, witchy atmosphere associated with the franchise. The production design, costumes and magical elements give it the expected Practical Magic feel. However, the visual polish cannot completely hide the screenplay's problems. Some of the magical sequences feel more functional than exciting, while several ideas appear designed mainly to remind viewers of the original.

The film also repeats familiar imagery and moments instead of building a distinctive visual identity of its own. This contributes to the feeling that the sequel is deliberately trying to recreate a 1990s experience rather than move the franchise forward.

What Are The Weak Points?

• Dated storytelling
• Overlong runtime
• Predictable plot
• Weak supporting characters

Is Practical Magic 2 Worth Watching?

Watch it if you:

• Love the original film
• Enjoy witchy fantasy
• Like Sandra Bullock
• Want nostalgic entertainment

Skip it if you:

• Expect fresh storytelling
• Dislike long sequels
• Want stronger character development
• Prefer modern fantasy

Final Verdict

Practical Magic 2 has the stars, the magic and enough nostalgia to remind audiences why the Owens sisters became memorable in the first place. Sandra Bullock and Nicole Kidman still have an easy chemistry, and their scenes together are easily the film's strongest element.

Unfortunately, the sequel struggles to turn that chemistry into a satisfying new story. Its dated ideas, lengthy runtime and dependence on nostalgia make it feel less like a necessary continuation and more like a delayed reunion.

Rating: 2/5

Also Read: The Weight Review: Ethan Hawke Leads 1933 Crime Drama